Carissa Garpstas

Team Owner | Real Estate Advisor | Operations
IMG_2070 (1)

Hi! I’m Carissa Garpstas, a Lancaster County real estate agent, longtime Pennsylvania resident, and proud graduate of Millersville University with a BA in Mathematics.

Before real estate, I spent eight years in the hospitality and tourism industry, traveling to trade shows and promoting Lancaster County to domestic and international tour groups. That experience gave me a unique opportunity to really get to know this area - from its small towns and neighborhoods to the local businesses and hidden gems that make Lancaster County such a special place to call home.

I earned my real estate license in 2016, and today I love putting that local knowledge to work for my clients. Whether I’m helping someone buy their first home, relocate to Lancaster County, find a home that better fits their family, or sell a property they’ve loved for years, I want the experience to feel personal from beginning to end.

I take the time to understand what really matters to my clients. Schools, churches, commute times, neighborhoods, community, and even where you’ll grab your morning coffee can all play a part in finding the right place. And when it’s time to sell, I bring that same personal approach to preparing, pricing, marketing, and negotiating the sale of your home.

I’m also proud to be a co-founder of the Koch Garpstas Realty Group, where our philosophy is simple: Clients for Life. I want to be someone my clients can trust and turn to long after settlement.

When I’m not working with clients, my husband Dave and I are busy keeping up with our five kids. You can usually find me at gymnastics, baseball, soccer, dance, or wandering a local park or trail that conveniently ends somewhere near an ice cream shop.

And if you need a Lancaster County coffee shop recommendation, I’m definitely your person. I practically run on coffee and would be more than happy to meet you at one of my favorite local spots.

At the end of the day, my goal is simple: provide exceptional service, be someone my clients can trust, and make buying or selling a home feel a little less overwhelming and a lot more personal.

In the Words of my Clients

Success Stories

"We appreciated the service we received from Sharon McDonnell throughout the entire buying process. Sharon was very responsive to us. She always responded promptly and helpfully to our questions. She was thorough in her answers. She put in Saturda…
"Koch Garpstas realty group came highly recommended.. Carissa is very professional and knows the market where we were selling very well.. Very pleased with the quick and calm experience in her hands. Always there to answer any questions we had.. A ver…
"I had a great experience with Koch Garpstas Reality Group. They provided excellent service, were professional, helpful, and made the whole process easy and smooth. I really appreciate their support and would definitely recommend Reality Group to oth…
"Matt and his team were exceptional to work with. The communication was outstanding. Matt helped us find our piece of paradise and we are so thankful! The process was made so much easier than we thought it would be. I would recommend them to anyone…

Search

Listings

Explore the rich heritage and tranquil countryside of Lancaster County. Discover your dream home amidst its scenic beauty and tight-knit communities with our listings.

Read our client success stories

We Love Our Clients

"We appreciated the service we received from Sharon McDonnell throughout the entire buying process. Sharon was very responsive to us. She always responded promptly and helpfully to our questions. She was thorough in her answers. She put in Saturday hours to complete our offer, and got back to us Sunday with news of seller's acceptance. She coordinated with seller's agent, as necessary. We wou…
"Koch Garpstas realty group came highly recommended.. Carissa is very professional and knows the market where we were selling very well.. Very pleased with the quick and calm experience in her hands. Always there to answer any questions we had.. A very knowledgeable and sincere realtor.. you won’t be disappointed."
"I had a great experience with Koch Garpstas Reality Group. They provided excellent service, were professional, helpful, and made the whole process easy and smooth. I really appreciate their support and would definitely recommend Reality Group to others. Thank you for the great service!"
"Matt and his team were exceptional to work with. The communication was outstanding. Matt helped us find our piece of paradise and we are so thankful! The process was made so much easier than we thought it would be. I would recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell!"
"Amazing team that truly knows the market and cares deeply about each of their clients. Highly recommend them!"
"I was looking for a home to call my own and I didn’t have a great deal of time to make it happen.. Matt has been tremendous with both his help and willingness to work around my schedule! I have been blessed to have him in my corner! Thank you sir.."
"Matthew Koch provided exceptional service from the first walkthrough to settlement. Matt and Kaylin-office were always available to answer any questions throughout the process."
"After the passing of our father, Matt helped my brother and I sell our childhood home. He made the process simple and painless. He came well-recommended and met or exceeded all of our expectations."
"Carissa was recommended by my son in law who is a real estate investor. Carissa walked us through the process prior to making the commitment to work with her team, and our experience went pretty much exactly as described. We will be purchasing another property in the future and we will be working with Carissa which is about the best endorsement I could give. A very satisfied customer!"

New to the market

Handpicked Listings

View all

Ready to take

The next step?

Not sure if now's the right time to buy or sell? Need a reliable contractor? I would love to get to know more about you and your needs!